I feel like that guy is trying too hard to be Totalbiscuit. Imitating his fixation on graphics options, emphasizing "first impressions," generally complaining about ridiculous crap. I'm surprised he didn't demand an FOV slider--it's a visual novel, it doesn't need an in-depth options menu. Even Totalbiscuit gets that, come on.
If he'd complained about the combat lag, (which is an engine issue) then fine, but he hadn't even gotten to combat by that point.
-Complains about unskippable text, misses the "skip" setting in the options menu (after griping about its limitations) and in the game's interface itself.
-Demanding everything have voice acting. Yes, because indie companies releasing their games for free can afford to narrate everything. Do you want someone to read books aloud to you too, or is that also too much work?
-This is just painful to watch. He ignores the text instructions and then royally screws up, then blames the game for it. "I don't know if that's the way it goes, I really don't know." Well, maybe if you spent less time griping about the lack of voice acting and read the damn text then you would.
-"I didn't feel any sense of accomplishment whatsoever, because you were just destroying a piece of cardboard. That's what it looked like, anyway" What? You're playing the tutorial mission, and blew up one ship. Unless you're griping about the graphics, in which case **** you.
"So attack then, pony! It's not doing anything." Oh, I dunno, how about you try CLICKING ON THE ENEMY.
"So that tiny ship has thousands of missiles, and yet, I have run out." Well, yeah, it's a missile frigate. All it has are missiles, you're carrying ammo and power for flak, lasers, artillery, and the Vanguard cannon. Also, your ship was under construction and unfinished, if you had paid attention to the flavor text. Also, gameplay balance. Not a difficult concept
It does seem like he's playing the version without tooltips. That's an actual problem, but he doesn't even mention it, instead complaining about trivial and subjective "problems." And that one's been fixed, anyhow.
There are legitimate things to complain about in this game. His grievances are not among them. Most of his complaints boil down to "I don't like this genre, ergo this is a bad game" or are totally irrelevant altogether. What a terrible "review"