I consider myself to be a hardcore gamer - and a relatively old one at that. You won't see or hear me doing the 'fanboy' thing simply because I like one element in a game or perhaps even the image of the company in question. My hard drive is chock full of games of almost every genre to suit whatever mood I'm in at the time. I do, however, have a generalized list of
unwanted features that scare me away from purchasing a title and the amount of games this list covers is growing with new trends that I don't care for at all.
** Online-based copy protection (Steam, Ubisoft, etc. - see below before getting upset)
** Uni-tasker games which aren't replayable
** Movie-based titles
** Subscription-based titles
** Endless Micro-Transaction games
** Botched sequels of great games
** Console-based PC ports
** Dumbed-down PC versions (eg: Console-friendly sequels)
** Non-existent customer support
** Evasive copy protection schemes (Starforce, etc.)
** No user-definable qualities (editors, options, settings, etc)
Now, I know what you are thinking and I've been told this at least 100 times by Steamfolk; "Then you aren't a hardcore gamer!". My response is that I've been gaming on the PC exclusively since 1990 or so and I have played literally thousands of games in my time and won't fall for every gimmick that is devised for the public. Even in this day and age when the above criteria stifles about 90% of the PC gaming market for me, there are still tons of games made today that make the permanent migration to my hard drive. Unfortunately, most of the big corporate blockbuster companies generally just don't get it because they are corporate entities at this stage and are out for blood and money (Bobby Kotlick of Activision anyone?).
This brings me to AI War. I might not play it every night...or maybe even every week, but I always keep coming back to it because I know it will challenge me and the content is ever-changing. It meets my personal criteria above (yes, there is a non-Steam version) and is one of those gems that will permanently remain on my system - long after Windows 7 dries up and blows away in the wind. I believe that while I have about 60 games on my system, I balance them to suit my needs to keep me interested. Too much of anything is not good and moderation is the key for me, but one thing definitely rings true - AI War has reached the Hall of Game Fame in my book and will remain with me for a long time.
On top of it defying all of the above I listed, I note the following features:
* Scalability of size
* Scalability of difficulty
* No-nonsense multiplayer
* Modest system resources
* Intense strategy and tactics
* Massive scope of command
* Emergent & cunning AI
* Community interaction
* Growing database of content
* Extremely fun and engaging
* Modest price range
All that to me is the real deal. This is what I whip out my debit card for and hope other game companies are listening. I'm not one of those bandwagon types, but it's really hard to go wrong with this product no matter how you look at it. If any case of boredom does seep into your experience, I would definitely look into a more well-rounded gaming cycle and then revisit when the mood strikes.
P.S. I actually bought Tyrian when it came out.